5 Signs Your Business Should Hire a Local SEO Expert - Graphic design

5 Signs Your Business Should Hire a Local SEO Expert

If you run a business, you’ve probably heard a lot of chatter about local SEO, and the question is always hanging around – “Should I hire a local SEO expert or go it alone?”
Maybe you’ve read a few articles about improving your performance with Google. You probably get tons of sales calls from people promising instant results.

2024 is almost upon us, and Google rankings are as volatile as they’ve ever been. In fact, Google, especially if your business is local or multi-local (operating on a local level in more than one region), is more complex than ever.

Your experience and intuition tell you this is the year you must get serious about SEO.
Most internet sessions start at a search engine, so there’s virtually nothing you can do that is more likely to deliver a positive ROI.

Two things to know for certain are…

  • Your prospects are using Google like previous generations used the phone book.
  • Your competitors are aggressively looking for ways to beat you to those prospects.

The challenge is that it’s basically impossible to stay on top of local SEO trends and run a business at the same time.

If you’re unsure whether you should hire an agency, we’re going to help you figure out if you need to hire someone to handle your SEO or if you can do it yourself.

Here’s my list to help you decide if your site needs a local SEO agency or whether you can put it off a little longer.

1. You’re Not Feeling the Google Love

Have you ever heard someone refer to the Google local 3 pack? It’s a grouping of the top 3 search results that Google considers to be most relevant to a local user’s search. So if someone in Cleveland, Ohio, searches for a dry cleaner using their mobile device, the 3 local dry cleaning businesses with the best SEO will show up right at the top of their search results page (SERP).

What does this mean for you? Well, if you’re a dry cleaner in Cleveland, you definitely want to show up in that user’s search. And if you want the best shot that this person will click on your link and find your store, getting into the local 3-pack should be your top priority.

You're Not Feeling the Google Love

But how can you do that? A Google search for dry cleaners in Cleveland returns more than 6 million results. But the vast majority of mobile users won’t scroll past the first page. Of the Google users who click on a link after searching, most click on a first-page link. And since the local 3 pack takes up the entire first page on many mobile devices, you really want to be in that top three.

How a local SEO expert can help

If your site hasn’t been getting a lot of traffic from Google, that probably means you’re not ranking very high on the SERP. Getting your link into one of those top spots is challenging and takes a lot of work. It also takes the kind of expertise that many non-SEO professionals lack.

A local SEO expert can go into your site’s background code and write, tweak, and add features that Google will love. They can leverage phrases, keywords, and topics that will improve your SERP ranking and increase your chances of landing in that local 3 pack.

So if you’re not feeling the Google love, consider hiring a local agency to help you stand out and leave the competition behind. If they have experience in your vertical – that’s even better.

2. You Haven’t Updated Your Web Copy Recently

Hey, we’re all busy. In fact, if you’re running a business, you passed “busy” at about 9:00 AM, and you’re fully in the weeds by noon most days. Who has time to update a website?

Unfortunately, if you want to attract customers and use your website to funnel leads and close sales, you really need fresh, useful content. If you haven’t done that in a while? Time to call a local SEO expert. Here’s why

Stay Relevant on Google

Google uses bots to crawl billions of web pages, searching for content that meets its users’ needs. They want people to find their search engine useful, so that means they have to fill their SERPs with fresh, relevant results. Your web copy from 1997 won’t strike Google as particularly fresh or relevant.

Google bots are looking for recently updated, well-written, and useful content. If a user searches for “how to change your own oil,” Google wants to show them articles and videos that were written recently with current car models in mind. They want to highlight content that gives a thorough, step-by-step description of the oil-changing process and that’s presented in a way that a novice can understand. And they want to direct users to local websites with a reputation for providing great content.

If you own an auto parts store with a locally optimized website and you’ve recently published a blog that does all that, you’ll probably rank higher than the shop that stopped updating 10 years ago.

Stay Relevant on Google

This is why it’s so important for businesses to frequently update their web copy. If you don’t have time to do it yourself, hire a local SEO expert to help. They’ll keep you relevant on Google, drive visitors to your site, and help you generate leads so that you can focus on running your business.

Maintaining Your Own Website

Today, many businesses choose to maintain their own websites. They think they’re saving themselves money. It’s fairly easy with programs like WordPress and Squarespace. Even someone with no coding experience at all can choose from a menu of pre-written website themes and create an attractive page layout.

The reality is they’re probably costing themselves a lot of money instead.

The tricky part is filling that website with Google-focused, locally optimized content. If you’re unfamiliar with schema markups, focus keywords, backlinks, and domain authority, this could be very difficult. A local SEO expert can help you with all of those things so that you can stay focused on your actual area of expertise.

3. You Haven’t Optimized for “Near Me” Searches

Certain location-based apps, like Google Maps and AroundMe, offer users the option to search for a local business in their immediate area. Let’s say an iPhone user is driving from Baltimore to Philadelphia to meet up with an old college roommate. Our Baltimore resident wants to know where she and her old friend can get a drink and catch up. She’s already using Google Maps for directions to Philly, so she taps on “explore” at the bottom of her screen, chooses “bars,” and voila! A list of the most relevant businesses that are close to her destination pops up.

You might have guessed where we’re going with this by now. Yes, if you own a bar, it is definitely in your best interest to have your business show up in that search.

The same goes for any other local business with a brick-and-mortar store: restaurants, car repair shops, record stores, and injury lawyers. The list goes on and on.

Smartphone users often search for nearby places with voice search as well. “Hey, Siri, find me a nearby Chinese restaurant.” Or “OK, Google, help me find a nearby gas station.”

You Haven't Optimized for Near Me Searches

The best way to ensure that a potential customer finds you when she’s searching for a nearby business is to optimize for nearby searches. In order to do that, you’ll have to find someone who understands how people search and how to tell Google that your website is a relevant result. A local SEO expert will understand how to best use keywords, search phrases, and other tools to give your business the boost it needs.

4. You Aren’t Getting the Results You Want

Businesses should always look ahead and seek out new ways to drive higher conversions and grow their customer base. Part of this process is factoring in new investments and ROI. If you’re looking for a way to get the biggest bang for your marketing buck, a local SEO expert can give it to you and then some.

Think about your current digital marketing activities. Are you advertising with Google and other search engines? Running a drip email campaign? Maintaining social media accounts?

Now ask yourself how much business these activities have pulled in. Many business owners say that they’ve given up on digital marketing because it just doesn’t pay off enough to justify the spending.

But a local SEO expert can improve the timing, positioning, and content of all these activities and more. Your marketing dollars should be spent on initiatives that increase your revenue. So it’s important to talk to someone who knows how to make that happen.

There’s a reason why SEO companies are open for business: their methods bring results.

Local SEO experts understand consumers and how they search. They can craft compelling content to snag search engine bots for top results. Even from your initial consultation, a worthy consultant should be able to pitch you a data-driven approach to growing your brand based on what they know about your target audience.

So if your marketing dollars aren’t bringing in the ROI, you were hoping for, talk to a local SEO expert to find out how he or she can help.

local seo expert

5. Keeping up with Changing SEO Rules Doesn’t Seem Worth It

To prevent scammy business practices and keep the market fair, Google updates its SEO rules pretty frequently, and they do it without telling anyone. Many people try to guess, but nobody but Google knows exactly how they choose which websites to rank highest.

Google does give people a few official suggestions for improving their rankings, but for the most part, experts have to figure it out through trial and error. These folks are constantly testing the rules to understand them better and put them to use for their clients.

This is why there are so many articles and blog posts about SEO. Experts who study Google’s algorithm and ranking results all day try to put what they know into helpful content that others can use to improve their rankings on the SERP. But there is so much information and so many rules, it’s way too time-consuming for a non-expert to try and understand it all.

Instead of wasting time trying to play catch up with new SEO rules and tactics, hire a reliable, local SEO expert who comes up with a plan for success.

Invest in a Local SEO Expert for Higher Returns

If you don’t already have a local SEO expert, it’s time to make that call. There is no digital marketing investment with a better return on investment.

Don’t know where to look? Give White Peak a call! We’ve got years of experience to help you improve your local SEO and drive customers to your business.

Looking for other insider tips on all things SEO and digital marketing? Comment below and tell us what you want us to address.

Related Posts


Get Exclusive Digital Marketing Tips

Learn how to get more traffic and convert more visitors with exclusive tips and insights that I only share with my VIP newsletter subscribers.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Tim always – I mean always – delivers the goods. His ability to see the true value proposition of an offering and then to communicate it to the prospect with crystal clarity is unmatched.

Digital marketing

Scott Morton

Network Designs

Yvette K.
Yvette K.
Memor Health
Read More
We have been with White Peak Marketing for about 3 years now. They re-designed our website, constantly update it for us, and take care of all of our SEO needs. It has been a game changer for traffic to our website and growing our business. Tim and his staff are professional, friendly and very responsive. I highly recommend their services.
Vincent M.
Vincent M.
Level AI
Read More
Tim and the crew at White Peak have been extremely helpful over the first year working with them. Any time we have a hiccup or even an emergency with our site, they go the extra yard to make sure everything gets taken care of in a timely manner. Highly recommend working with this team!
Angela B.
Angela B.
Kilpatrick Bullentini Law
Read More
White Peak has redesigned my web site and business logo, and they are managing my SEO. I can't say enough good things about Tim and his firm; they are responsive, creative, and do great work. Would highly recommend!

Next Steps...

Tell Us About Your Campaign

Get expert help and a free audit

By submitting this form you agree to our Privacy Policy.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.